Hertes of England
historic buildings consultancy
  • Elements
  • Materials
    • Stone
    • Brick
  • Journal
  • Regions
  • Projects

Gypsum and Lime Plaster Floors

The English Midlands has a long and rich vernacular tradition of constructing buildings, and its use of local materials often created regionally specific building technologies that we are still endeavouring to identify, understand and conserve.♱
Category: Materials
Tags: Architecture, Derbyshire, English Midlands, Gypsum, Hardwick Hall, Lichfield, Lime, Lincolnshire, Nottinghamshire, Staffordshire, Vernacular, Warwickshire
Detail of a gypsum plaster floor with a large variety of aggregates.

Within the context of historic architecture the term ‘vernacular’ is primarily used to describe buildings that have been constructed from materials that have usually been sourced from the locality in which the building is situated. Historically, this has meant the use of local stone, clay, timber, earth and straw to construct the walls and roofs of mainly farm buildings, cottages and other small domestic dwellings. However, as post-medieval vernacular traditions developed, other materials were used in different areas of the construction process and often for much larger buildings. The use of such materials, and the practices that accompanied them, have a long and complex history that is bound up with the social, cultural and economic traditions of different counties and their regional variations.

During the late 16th and early 17th centuries, throughout the English Midlands, a practice developed of using local gypsum and lime for mainly first and second floor flooring in a variety of vernacular buildings, as well as the much larger houses of the landed gentry. In 1611, John Speed published his Theatre of the Empire of Great Britaine, which explored the cultural, geological and topographical differences in each of England’s great counties. In Nottinghamshire, he describes the use of a ‘new’ building material that had found many uses. “Therein groweth a stone softer than Alabaster, but being burnt maketh a Plaister harder than that of Paris; wherewith they flower their upper rooms; for betwixt the joyists they lay only long bulrushes, and thereon spread this Plaister, which being throughly dire becomes most solide and hard, so that it seemeth rather to be firmestone than mortar, and is troad upon without all danger.” ♥

This ‘new’ material wasn’t really that new in the sense that it had been used for countless applications in other periods to serve both similar and different purposes. The use of earthen materials such as chalk, clay, lime and other types of binders had been used to create agricultural and domestic floors in buildings for centuries. Norman builders were known to use similar materials and methods to create the floors in their buildings. However, by the late 16th Century, in the English Midlands, the practice had matured to a reasonably sophisticated level with the materials being specifically selected for the purpose.

In the 17th century, John Speed’s identification of gypsum plaster floors in Nottinghamshire would not have been an isolated instance, as flooring of this type could have been found in many of the counties that make up the English Midlands. From as far north as Derbyshire and Lincolnshire to the more southern reaches of Warwickshire and Worcestershire and most counties in between, the use of both gypsum (calcium sulphate) and lime (calcium hydroxide) as the main constituent component of domestic flooring was reasonably common. 

An historic plaster floor with signs of repair (note the difference in colour).

The main ‘ingredient’ or binder needed to create the floors was burnt gypsum, which was created by ‘burning off’ lumps of gypsum rock at its source using large fires of wood and coal, a process John Farey perceived as extremely wasteful. Writing in his General View of the Agriculture and Minerals of Derbyshire (1813) he states “…the process of burning and preparing plaster for floors … is the most wasteful one that can be imagined: an immense pile of brush and billet wood was made, and upon it the old plaster and some new … was laid, and fired: after which, a number of men with flails, thrashed, and rather wasted and spread it about than pulverised it”.♦ After the gypsum had been fired it would be broken down into a powder and mixed with water to create the coarse binder used in the mix.

The floors, which typically ranged in thicknesses from 50mm – 100mm, consisted of a gypsum or lime based screed mix that was laid onto a suspended timber structure, or in some instances, directly onto the earth at ground level. At first and second floor level, where the mix would have been poured and spread directly onto a timber structure, various forms of straw or reed bedding would have been used to support the mix through its drying phase (resembling a crude form of shuttering). It is thought that most of the floors that were laid directly onto the earth would have perished over time due to the soluble properties of gypsum, however, some still remain in isolated locations, such as Lichfield Cathedral, where lime was more prevalent and modern building development hasn’t yet intervened.

Detail of straw bedding underneath a plaster floor in Derbyshire.

It is clear from research conducted over the last couple of decades that the use of gypsum and lime for the construction of floors varied from county to county, which was obviously linked to the readiness and availability of the materials. Earthen and plaster floors of this type were made from a number of elements that shared similar properties and capacities, such as reed, straw, clay, unburnt coal, crushed stone and brick and kiln ash (which probably acted as a type of pozzolan) but the binding ingredient was usually gypsum or lime (or a mixture of both). Some floors have even been found to contain oats and barley chaff, as in the Manor House in Bramcote, Nottingham.♣ The former Building Research Station, found that when analysing the floors at Old Hardwick Hall in Derbyshire (completed in 1597) that lime had been the main component, whereas at ‘nearby’ Bolsover Castle (completed in around 1620), the use of gypsum was identified as more dominant. ♣ This analysis also corresponds strongly with a statement attributed to Bess of Hardwick (Lady of the Manor at both Chatsworth and Hardwick) in 1556, in which, during a recorded consultation with her steward at Chatsworth regarding the specification for flooring, she states “cause the floor in my bedchamber to made even with either plaster, clay or lime.” ♣ The upper floors at Hardwick Hall were shown to contain red brick and local stone, as well as the lime binder. ♠

Floors made of this material were both necessary and desirable for a number of reasons, they offered a draught-free surface that was warm under foot with reasonably good sound insulation, as well as providing relatively substantial fire protection to living and sleeping spaces (this is perhaps why they are still often found in loft and attic spaces). They were also thought to have helped with reducing the amount of vermin within households, which is probably why Nicholson (a 19th century researcher), describes their use in Derbyshire as much used ‘for laying the floors of cheese rooms and granaries’.♦ The benefits of these floors had wide ranging appeal, so much so, they were still being constructed (in the English Midlands at least) well into the 19th century.

Detail of a plaster floor in the process of repair near the Staffordshire border.

Due to the range of materials used in the process of constructing these types of floors, the terminology that was historically used to describe them has changed over time. As Bess of Hardwick’s quote above indicates, there was at least some common knowledge of the ingredients that were used, which perhaps offers some hints towards why such a myriad of terms to describe them still exists. Historically, they were often just referred to as ‘plaster’ floors, however, we now use (sometimes incorrectly) more specific terms, such as ‘reed and plaster’, ‘lime plaster’, ‘lath and plaster’, ‘lime-ash’ and even ‘limecrete’, which is perhaps due to the textural similarities with its more modern Portland equivalent. However, at least in the Midlands, gypsum, due to its abundance and accessibility (gypsum can be found in most parts of England, but the Midlands contains significantly large deposits), was often the most dominant ingredient used in the construction of these types of floors, with lime being used significantly less, comparatively.

Cracks and fissures in plaster floors are extremely common.

Over the last two or three decades, with the advent of modern building development, many of these floors have been lost or damaged due mainly in part to a lack of knowledge regarding their composition and history. They can often provide an extremely un-level surface that seems at odds with our need for creating relatively modern interiors within the context of historic structures. Given the individual nature of their composition, they can often appear difficult to repair and many suffer from significant cracks or fissures, which is a reasonably common feature due their tendency to follow the line of constantly shifting timbers. Even the floors at Hardwick Hall (one of Derbyshire’s greatest country houses) bear the scars of many centuries of pounding footsteps and structural movement!

A gypsum plaster floor identified during a routine building survey in Derbyshire.

As our knowledge of the construction of these types of floors develops and the desire to retain the unique character they provide slowly increases, the more significant their presence will be in enabling us to truly understand how our regional vernacular traditions developed over the centuries before the Industrial Revolution took hold. The English Midlands witnessed many changes through those centuries, it would be a genuine shame to lose the material fabrics that provide the historical evidence of those changes, as well as a unique ‘window’ onto how we once lived.

♱ This article is dedicated to the late Anthony Goode, whose tireless work and unbounded curiosity provided a significant development in our identification, understanding and long-term conservation of gypsum and lime floors throughout the English Midlands.

References

♦ SPAB (Society for the Protection of Ancient Buildings), 2018, Gypsum Plaster Floors, Regional Technical Advice Note. (This advice note was authored by Anthony Goode DipBldgCons (RICS), IHBC).

♥ Quoted in The Pattern of English Building by Alec Clifton-Taylor, Faber & Faber, 1972, p. 352.

♣ Watt, D. & Colston, B., 2002, Analysis of Historic Lime and Gypsum Plaster Floors—Part One, Journal of Architectural Conservation, 8:1, 57-73.

♠ Watt, D., Colston, B. & Goode, A., 2002, Analysis of Historic Lime and Gypsum Plaster Floors—Part Two, Journal of Architectural Conservation, 8:2, 48-62.

← John Speed

About

Welcome to the Hertes of England historic building resource. We specialise in exploring the traditional buildings and vernacular architecture of the English Midlands. From timber-frame cottages to Victorian town houses and factories, we investigate a range of historic buildings and the skills, techniques and crafts that were used to create them.

Tags

Anglo Saxon Architecture Birmingham Black Country Derbyshire East Midlands English Midlands Georgian Gothic Henry Issac Stevens History Industrial Revolution Joseph Pickford Kingdom of Mercia Knowledge Leicestershire Lincolnshire Lunar Society Medieval Midlands Nottinghamshire R. W. Brunskill Romantic Staffordshire Vernacular Victorian Warwickshire World Heritage Site

Journal

  • John Speed "Therein groweth a stone softer than Alablaster, but being burnt maketh a Plaister harder than..."

    John Speed

  • Sidney R. Jones "One only has to travel over the mountains and moors of Lancashire, Yorkshire and Derbyshire..."

    Sidney R. Jones

  • Carole Ryan "Vernacular building tradition is one based upon time-immeriorial building techniques and the use of materials,..."

    Carole Ryan

Instagram

Yet more evidence of our growing obsession with la Yet more evidence of our growing obsession with late 17th and early 18th century dovecotes! Form, brick size and bond would probably put this one somewhere on the cusp. Their simple, pure, almost modern forms often belie their true purpose; not a machine for living as Le Corbusier might have said, but a machine for feeding!

#heritage #conservation #historicbuildings #architecture #dovecotes #brick #shropshire #thefabricofplaces
The Shropshire Union Canal was largely completed i The Shropshire Union Canal was largely completed in the mid 1830s and passed through the Midlands counties of Shropshire and Staffordshire. The Woodseaves cutting provided the engineer (Thomas Telford) with ample stone for the construction of various bridges and structures along this section. This bridge, No 57, as well as No 58 are two of the best examples and are both currently designated as Grade II.

#heritage #conservation #architecture #canals #shropshire #canalandrivertrust #thefabricofplaces
Very rarely do we pass through the city of Derby w Very rarely do we pass through the city of Derby without visiting at least one of the remaining works by one of the greatest iron smiths of the 18th century. Robert Bakewell of Derby is seen by many to represent the most distinctive break with what was then the dominant French style of Jean Tijou, who Bakewell was thought to have worked with at Hampton Court at the very beginning of his career.

During our most recent foray into the city, we managed to spend some time admiring his magnificent chancel screen at the Church of All Saints, now the city’s Cathedral. Redesigned by James Gibbs in the early 1720s and built by Francis Smith of Warwick, the new church could have been said to symbolise the emerging confidence of a town whose reputation for trade, commerce and culture was growing rapidly.

Bakewell regularly worked with the firm of Francis Smith and would later work with James Gibbs on his designs for the Radcliffe Camera in Oxford. However, in this instance, the finished work was elevated above that of a regular commission to a singular masterpiece, easily comparable to that of his much celebrated arbour at Melbourne Hall. Despite its greatness, the screen did fall into relatively poor condition during the 19th century, but was magnificently restored and adapted by Haslam in the early 1900s, to the composition and condition in which we see it today. 

It is perhaps the finest piece of 18th century decorative wrought iron work, in the English style, anywhere in England. Nikolaus Pevsner once remarked that it was ‘the most important possession in the Cathedral’, and when you stand in front of it, you can clearly see why.

#heritage #conservation #craftsman #ironwork #wroughtiron #cathedral #churches #derby #melbourne #derbyshire #oxford #thefabricofplaces
Unusual examples of the historic built environment Unusual examples of the historic built environment can often be found in the strangest of places. This late 17th century dovecote is situated at the heart of a 1970s housing estate on the outskirts of Wolverhampton. Originally part of a large farmstead, it is now the only remaining structure of an historic agricultural holding that was thought to date from the 13th century.

The farm was acquired in the 1860s by the then Wolverhampton Corporation, who developed the land to form part of the local sewage treatment works, which operated up until the mid 20th century. By the early 1960s, the Corporation had demolished most of the buildings on the site, including an early 17th century brick gatehouse. By the mid 1970s, the land had been largely cleared for the development of a new housing estate, but for some reason the dovecote was spared! 

It was restored in the 1980s and again more recently with the support of the National Lottery Heritage Fund. It is perhaps one of the most unusual settings for a structure of its type, standing next to a former pub (now a church) and overlooked by a modern shopping precinct. We are guessing the locals don’t use it as intended, however, it should be greatly admired if only for escaping, relatively unscathed, from the demolition crazed 1970s! It is currently designated as Grade II.

#heritage #conservation #architecture #agriculture #dovecote #wolverhampton #westmidlands #nationallotteryheritagefund #thefabricofplaces
Very rarely do the qualities of vernacular simplic Very rarely do the qualities of vernacular simplicity, rhythmic form and heritage significance combine in such a way as they do at Essex Bridge in the Staffordshire village of Great Haywood. It is thought to have originally taken its name from a timber structure that was either built or improved upon by the Earl of Essex (Robert Devereux) in the late 16th century, as a passage over the River Trent to his family home at nearby Chartley Castle.

It was reconstructed in stone in the middle of the 17th century and, at over 100 meters in length, it is widely considered to be one of the country’s longest packhorse bridges still in existence. Despite its age, its form is thought to have remained largely unchanged since the time of its construction and it is currently dual designated as both a Scheduled Monument and a Grade I designated heritage asset.

#heritage #conservation #architecture #vernacular #engineering #rivers #rivertrent #canalandrivertrust #medieval #staffordshire #thefabricofplaces
Whilst it’s perhaps fair to say that Vanbrugh li Whilst it’s perhaps fair to say that Vanbrugh lived an extremely ‘colourful’ life, even by today’s standards, it’s perhaps equally fair to say that this great artist didn’t leave us with enough of his classically unorthodox, architectural creations! However, for this reason, the buildings he did leave us with are perhaps made more significant by their rarity. Our last visit to one of his creations reminded us that he designed some of the best ‘back doors’ of the early 18th century!

#heritage #conservation #architecture #classicism #baroque #northumberland #nationaltrust #thefabricofplaces
Follow on Instagram

Copyright © 2022 Hertes of England.